Dane Scarimbolo and Dominique Torgerson, shown in this October 2019 file photo, run Four Horsemen Brewery in Kent. They were almost shut down in late 2017 by King County, which after years of letting them operate a brewery and taproom, decided they were in violation of county code. (Aaron Kunkler/Sound Publishing)

Dane Scarimbolo and Dominique Torgerson, shown in this October 2019 file photo, run Four Horsemen Brewery in Kent. They were almost shut down in late 2017 by King County, which after years of letting them operate a brewery and taproom, decided they were in violation of county code. (Aaron Kunkler/Sound Publishing)

King County Council approves controversial winery, brewery ordinance

After five years, the county has updated regulations surrounding alcohol production and tasting.

The King County Metropolitan Council narrowly approved a controversial alcohol producer and tasting room ordinance that will affect businesses and conservation efforts in unincorporated areas of King County.

The council voted 5-4 to approve the ordinance at its Dec. 4 meeting, which saw public comment from more than 50 people stretch into multiple hours ahead of the vote. Representatives of neighbors and farmers in the Sammamish Valley voiced their opposition to the ordinance, as did conservation groups and alcohol producers themselves. The ordinance passed with council members Claudia Balducci, Reagan Dunn, Kathy Lambert, Joe McDermott and Pete von Reichbauer voting to approve it.

“This has been very heavy lifting. It’s a complicated piece of legislation with lots of spreadsheets and we’ve looked at spreadsheet upon spreadsheet,” Lambert said. “We’ve worked very hard to listen to everybody.”

Lambert has been a supporter of the ordinance, as has Balducci, with both working to find a solution balancing the needs of competing business, farm and conservation interests. The former code had not been updated since 2003, and Balducci said the code hadn’t anticipated alcohol producers and tasting rooms setting up in rural-zoned areas of the county.

“My interest is that we have clear rules, that they’re fair, that they are enforceable,” Balducci said.

Other council members voiced concerns, including Larry Gossett, who noted the large number of people who regularly attended meetings and voiced concerns since spring 2018, when the council took up the issue. He ultimately voted no on the ordinance.

“A wide variety of farmers, trade organizations that represent either breweries, wineries, distilleries — this is kind of unique to me — or represented farmers and homeowners all saying that we are so concerned about passage of this ordinance that we took time out of our schedules and came down here to let you know why we are opposed,” he said.

Council member Rod Dembowski also voted against the ordinance. After thanking Lambert and Balducci for taking up the issue, Dembowski said concerns voiced by conservation groups like Futurewise ultimately led him to believe some of the ordinance could have negative effects on conservation efforts throughout the county.

“It’s a red flag. It’s not a yellow flag, it’s a red flag for me,” he said.

Council members at the meeting said they expected lawsuits or even challenges filed with the Growth Management Hearings Board. Dembowski had proposed an amendment that would have delayed the implementation of the ordinance until a month after challenges were settled. The amendment was struck down in a 5-4 vote. Balducci, Jeanne Kohl-Welles, McDermott, von Reichbauer and Lambert voted no.

The ordinance will prohibit small wineries, breweries and distilleries from operating as home businesses and instead move them into a series of scaling production tiers. Alcohol producers that are on agriculture zones would be required to grow 60% of their materials on-site. In rural areas, businesses will have to produce onsite what they sell.

Dominique Torgerson runs Four Horsemen Brewery in Kent with Dane Scarimbolo. She said Dec. 4 that the ordinance will affect businesses.

“It’s likely that this is going to kill some businesses, for sure,” she said.

Four Horsemen Brewery began selling beer in 2015 after the owners thought they had received the necessary permits. But in 2017, they started getting notices from King County saying they were out of compliance with the county code. Torgerson said it was unclear whether their business will be grandfathered into compliance with the new ordinance.

A pilot program area was also created and will affect around a dozen parcels in the Sammamish Valley near the Woodinville Wine District. The pilot program will allow businesses that were in violation of code surrounding tasting rooms and alcohol production to stay put as the county studies the effects of their businesses. A second overlay zone was cut from the ordinance earlier this year.

Neighbors in recent years have said that some businesses operating in rural buffer zones and other areas around the Sammamish Valley have been functioning as bars, with little actual production happening on-site. While the valley has served as a flashpoint, the ordinance takes effect countywide, with small brewers as far away as Kent worrying about its impacts.


In consideration of how we voice our opinions in the modern world, we’ve closed comments on our websites. We value the opinions of our readers and we encourage you to keep the conversation going.

Please feel free to share your story tips by emailing editor@mi-reporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.mi-reporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) We reserve the right to edit letters, but if you keep yours to 300 words or less, we won’t ask you to shorten it.

In this September 2019 photo, George Kirkish, owner and founder of Palouse Winery on Vashon-Maury Island, pours a glass of wine for Lori Coots during tasting room hours. (Kevin Opsahl/Sound Publishing)

In this September 2019 photo, George Kirkish, owner and founder of Palouse Winery on Vashon-Maury Island, pours a glass of wine for Lori Coots during tasting room hours. (Kevin Opsahl/Sound Publishing)

[flipp]

More in News

A shot from June 2020 graduation. Photo by Joe Chen.
How will school look this fall on Mercer Island?

After Superintendent Donna Colosky announced July 24 that the 2020-‘21 school year would begin remotely, a July 30 webinar was held by the MISD to confirm more details about the fall.

Primary election 2020: Who will emerge as Inslee’s challenger?

Voting ends Tuesday in an election without big rallies and fund-raisers and face-to-face debates

Sex ed, local control at heart of race for WA state schools chief

Incumbent Chris Reykdal faces five foes who argue he’s pushing too many state policies on school districts.

Groveland Beach. File photo
Groveland Beach Park closed until further notice

The city said the closure is in response to COVID-19-related safety guidelines not being followed and other concerns.

File photo.
Cougar reportedly spotted on Mercer Island Wednesday

The case has been since been transferred to the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife.

Community webinar regarding 2020-‘21 school year set for July 30

The event, to be held over Zoom, starts at 5:30 p.m.

Image courtesy King County.
King County looking for Conservation Futures Advisory Committee applicants

Committee meetings are typically held on Mercer Island.

The crash occurred the morning of July 28. Photo courtesy Mercer Island Police Department Facebook
Seaplane crashes near Hunts Point

The pilot, on board alone, sustained minor injuries.

Most Read