Council passes moratorium; exempts Hines development

New construction permits won't be allowed in Mercer Island for the next four months - except on buildings under two stories and the Hines mixed-use development.

  • Tuesday, February 3, 2015 4:46pm
  • News

There was a full house at the Feb. 2 Council meeting as a moratorium on downtown development was discussed. The Council voted 6-1 to impose a moratorium but exempted new buildings under two stories and the Hines development.

Reporting for this article took place at a meeting after the Reporter deadline. A different version of this story, “New construction may be put on hold,” will run in Wednesday’s print edition of the Mercer Island Reporter.

In front of a full house, the Mercer Island City Council established a four-month moratorium on new construction downtown – but it exempts buildings under two stories and the proposed Hines mixed-use development in the heart of Town Center.

Pressure on the decision came from a group of residents and supporters of ‘Save our Suburbs’ (SOS), who want to evaluate the impacts of increased density before moving forward with new projects, and from developers who said that a moratorium could negatively impact plans to bring retailers like Pagliacci Pizza and Whole Foods to the Island and create a vibrant downtown village.

SOS supporters argued that growth in the Town Center affects the whole Island and could overload Island infrastructure, roads and schools. They urged the Council to consider a moratorium while the city continues the Comprehensive Plan and Town Center design processes that were started last year.

City officials held an open house on Jan. 29 to discuss the Comprehensive Plan update, Town Center visioning and preparation for Sound Transit’s light rail – all of which have potential to significantly change the North-end of Mercer Island.

The issue of a moratorium was discussed at the Council’s planning session on Jan. 23 and placed on the agenda for their Feb. 2 meeting. It passed 6-1, with Councilmember Mike Cero voting against it because it exempts Hines.

Moratoria are used by land-use planners to preserve the status quo while formulating a more permanent development strategy. Mercer Island’s moratorium will be imposed “on the submission or acceptance of applications for any building permits or any other land development permits or approvals for major new construction (in the) Town Center zone” for four months on buildings over two stories. This means that other projects, like a new Pagliacci Pizza location, will be able to move forward with permitting.

More than 100 people attended the Feb. 2 Council meeting. About 35 addressed the Council during public comments, including residents – almost all of whom were in support of a moratorium – as well as business owners and a Hines developer who read a letter from Whole Foods indicating interest in an Island location.

Tom King, who owns the property on which Hines will be built, said that the developer is responsible and community-oriented. Deputy Mayor Dan Grausz said that he didn’t want the city to “put a cool blanket” on projects like Hines that can provide something that many community members want.

“If opportunity is out there and we do something to kill it, a lot of people on the Island might be mad,” Grausz said.

Cero said that the anxiety caused by the Hines massing study photo was why the Council was having the discussion in the first place, and that exempting it from a moratorium would be counterproductive. Other Councilmembers said that seeming to target one project could open the city up to a lawsuit.

Grausz said he was also concerned about the photo when he first saw it and thought it looked like a “Fort Knox” in the middle of Town Center, but that it’s a massing study, not a design for the building.

Development Services Director Scott Greenberg said that he wasn’t aware of any projects besides Hines that are over two stories and in the pipeline in the next four months, leaving residents to wonder to which projects the moratorium will apply. But the four-month deadline closely mirrors the timelines for the Comprehensive Plan update and Town Center visioning, and the duration of the moratorium can be extended with another vote.

Many residents in attendance left the meeting in frustration when conversations about exempting Hines began.

“A large group of attendees, who stayed for about four hours, stood up and left after the moratorium became so watered down it was meaningless,” said SOS group leader Tom Acker.

Acker said that “the goal of the moratorium is only to slow the process down long enough to make sure there is proper definition in the codes to protect the community’s interests.”

He said that residents have been receiving emails from a Hines developer stating that “a moratorium would stop our project, causing the city to lose a civic plaza, public parking and potentially an upscale grocery store.”

“If the tradeoff is a specialty grocer versus increased density, then I would submit the Island may want to forego a Whole Foods,” Acker said.

Islanders were encouraged by both sides to write letters to City Councilmembers, who want to know what Islanders think.

The open house was a first step in a new public outreach process that aims for greater transparency and communication with citizens.

“There’s been a lot of public interest in this, which is a good thing,” said Mayor Bruce Bassett. “Public outreach and involvement will happen regardless of whether there’s a moratorium.”

A public hearing on the moratorium will be scheduled for 7 p.m. on March 2.

The open house also focused on the issue of providing commuter parking, with the impending closure of the South Bellevue Park and Ride and arrival of light rail.

Hines developers said they could provide more than 200 commuter parking spaces in exchange for an extra story. The current maximum number of stories allowed is five, which some Islanders feel is already too high.

Phase two of the Town Center visioning process is beginning soon, and involves more public outreach to determine what Islanders want to see in their downtown. The Comprehensive Plan update is set to be adopted on June 30.



More in News

Malena Gaces, left, and other members of Washington CAN protest unfair move-out charges and alleged discriminatory behavior outside Kitts Corner Apartments in Federal Way in 2018. Sound Publishing file photo
King County could increase tenant protections

The council is considering ordinances designed to help renters.

The 2015 Wolverine Fire in the Okanogan-Wenatchee National Forest near Lake Chelan. Photo courtesy of the Washington Department of Natural Resources.
The smoky summer that wasn’t

While Washington had a mild season, wildfires burned near the Arctic.

Former Mercer Island City Council candidate Joy Langley posted a photo of her various credentials — including her Cornell degree — on her website during her campaign after a group of residents questioned her education credentials. File photo
Prosecutors will not charge former candidate who allegedly lied to voters

Vetting of candidate information is left up to citizens.

Natalie DeFord/staff photo
                                From left, Ashley Hay and Olivia Lippens with baby Monroe in protesting the bus intercept plan in front of the future Mercer Island light rail station.
Moms, business owners, residents oppose bus intercept

Daily rider estimates debated and not yet certain.

Dane Scarimbolo and Dominique Torgerson run Four Horsemen Brewery in Kent. They were almost shut down in late 2017 by King County, which after years of letting them operate a brewery and taproom, decided they were in violation of county code. Aaron Kunkler/staff photo
Proposed winery ordinance irks King County farmers, neighbors and businesses

Concerns include more traffic, higher land prices, code enforcement and compliance.

Balducci runs against Hirt for District 6 county council seat

The former Bellevue mayor is essentially running unopposed.

Washington Gov. Jay Inslee after speaking with reporters Aug. 22 in Seattle. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
Lawmakers to governor: How dare you mess with our budget!

They want Jay Inslee to halt his planned $175 million reallocation of state transportation dollars.

“We are one,” King County Sheriff Mitzi G. Johanknecht said in regard to the recent teen deaths due to fentanyl overdose. Left: Sammamish mayor Christie Malchow, King County Sheriff Mitzi G. Johanknecht and Sammamish Police Chief Michelle Bennett. Madison Miller / staff photo
Two Skyline High School students die from fentanyl overdose

The Sammamish police department, city of Sammamish, school districts join forces to prevent future teen fentanyl deaths.

Most Read