Panthers defeat Islanders in loser-out playoff football game

Bonney Lake Panthers running back Jason Day put together a game for the ages against the Mercer Island Islanders in a winner-to-state, loser-out playoff game.

Day rumbled for seven rushing touchdowns and had one receiving touchdown in Bonney Lake’s 56-42 victory against Mercer Island on Nov. 5 at Sunset Chev Stadium in Sumner. The Islanders finished the 2016 season with an overall record of 5-6. Bonney Lake head coach Jason Silbaugh said Day is one of the best players on the Panthers roster.

“He is a competitor. He plays both ways and he doesn’t come off the field. He is just a solid football player. He had a heck of a performance. It was pretty impressive,” Silbaugh said.

Mercer Island junior quarterback Nikhil Nayar, who connected with Will Krause, Cole Miller and Mitchell Mandt on touchdown passes in the loss, was impressed with Day’s performance.

“He probably broke 100 tackles today,” Nayar said as he shook his head. “He had five guys around him and he was just breaking off runs.”

Despite Bonney Lake’s excellence in the running game, Mercer Island kept the game close throughout with its prolific offensive attack. The Islanders cut the Panthers lead to seven points on four different occasions over the course of the game.

“It is a playoff game. We had to go back and fight. I told the guys the game is not over until the clock hits triple zeros,” Nayar said. “We had to keep fighting and just keep going and going. That is what we did.”

Mercer Island senior running back Jordano Mark, a gritty player who played in the game with an injured knee, had three rushing touchdowns in the final contest of his high school football career. Mark’s 22-yard touchdown run with 2:21 left in the third quarter which cut Bonney Lake’s lead to 35-28, was vintage Mark. He appeared to be stopped for a short gain but busted through the Panthers defense for the score. Silbaugh knew the Islanders wouldn’t go down without a fight.

“They fought hard and they never gave up. They just kept fighting the whole time. They made our defense look silly at times and that is pretty good. Our defense is pretty decent,” Silbaugh said.

Mercer Island head coach Brett Ogata was proud of his team’s effort in the final contest of the 2016 season.

“They just kept battling and kept going. These guys should keep their heads up. They played awesome. Our kids made some heroic plays today. Honestly, we just got beat by a better team today,” Ogata said.

In consideration of how we voice our opinions in the modern world, we’ve closed comments on our websites. We value the opinions of our readers and we encourage you to keep the conversation going.

Please feel free to share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) We reserve the right to edit letters, but if you keep yours to 300 words or less, we won’t ask you to shorten it.


More in Sports

WIAA delays start dates for fall sports

Football practices to begin Sept. 5, all other sports planned for Sept. 7.

Ed Pepple (center). File photo
Legendary Mercer Island coach celebrated on sports podcast

On Scorebook Live Today, coach Matt Logie discussed the legacy of his grandfather, Ed Pepple.

Rounding the bases: MIHS Baseball holds caravan for varsity seniors

The season was cut short for Mercer Island High School’s varsity baseball… Continue reading

No-show season: WIAA announces cancellation of spring sports, activities

Due to the school closure extension, the cancellation includes all practices, competitions, tournaments and championships, WIAA says.

There’s still hope for spring sports, WIAA announces

Washington Interscholastic Activities Association making contingency plans for high school sports competitions after extension of stay home order.

The WIAA announced Wednesday that if schools reopen at the conclusion of the six-week statewide shutdown ordered last week by Gov. Jay Inslee, then the state championships will go on as planned. (WIAA photo)
WIAA still hoping to hold state championships in May

But if the school shutdown extends past April 24, those championships could be in jeopardy.

Islanders possess young talent on soccer pitch

The Mercer Island boys soccer team awaits the new season.

Mercer Island wrestlers place at state folkstyle wrestling championships

Four Mercer Island elementary and middle school students placed at the state… Continue reading

Athletic practices and competitions cancelled through April 24 due to coronavirus outbreak

By Andy Nystrom and Benjamin Olson Gov. Jay Inslee announced on March… Continue reading

Games are being postponed in response to coronavirus outbreak

In response to the recent coronavirus outbreak, Eastside schools are taking precautions… Continue reading

Mercer Island Football Club teams net championships

Boys and girls soccer teams from Mercer Island Football Club dominated at… Continue reading

Preparing for the first pitch

The Mercer Island baseball team is going into the new season with a deep pitching staff.